It was the fall of 1996, a lunar eclipse was looming, and the world was different. Back in Boulder the four of us—my younger brother, my old friend Hones, my wife, Nina, and me—had semi-secured four bikes to the back of a rental Saab, crammed our backpacks and ourselves inside, and pointed the car toward the canyons of southeast Utah.
Back then none of us carried phones and the internet was a novelty. We wouldn’t get our first phones until five years later, after 9 /11, and we would have laughed if you’d suggested that one day phones would be glued to our hands and we would spend half our lives on computers sending mail to each other.
There was a whole lot else we didn’t know back then. For one, we didn’t know about the eclipse. For another, Nina and I had no idea that soon we would move away from Colorado and that, a couple years down the line, we would become parents to a daughter. Meanwhile my brother hadn’t been officially diagnosed yet, and although he’d had some trouble in recent months, we had no idea that the end of our trip would mark the beginning of a nearly thirty-year battle with mental illness, a battle that would find him in and out of institutions and intermittently homeless.
He had done pretty well early in the trip. The first night, after the six-hour drive, we couldn’t find a campsite and simply threw our sleeping bags out on the sandy banks of the Colorado River. We fell asleep to the lapping water and the next day we took an eight-hour bike ride through the red rocks. The ride was not supposed to take eight hours, but we got lost and for a while we were near panic as we tried to find our way before we ran out of water. When we finally made it back to the trail, we pushed on in an exhausted death march for the last hour or so. My brother, despite falling a couple times and bloodying his elbows and knees, acquitted himself well. Before we left on the trip, he had talked about how words had taken control of him and how he always felt watched and judged.
“I want to just not think, and do hard labor for a while,” he’d said.
“Is this enough hard labor for you?” I said as we pedaled the final mile.
He nodded.
The dirt path led us on like a mirage: We rode over orange rock backed by thin hoodoos like dorsal fins below blue levitating mountains. Then, as we biked toward this dream place, a near-full moon rose over the mountains. I knew Hones was exhausted, and irritated at me for getting us lost, but I couldn’t stop myself from babbling on about how beautiful everything was. Back then we didn’t all have handy cameras and Hones was our group photographer, so I said, “Look at the moon. You’ve got to get a picture!”
He ignored me, kept pedaling with his head down, grimly focused on the last stretch of road.
I persisted: “Look at the moon. Take a picture of the moon.”
He stopped and glared at me.
“Fuck the moon,” he said.
We made camp for the next few days where I always camped back then: Indian Creek below the hobbit wonderland of Hamburger Rock, BLM land just shy of the official entrance of the Needles section of Canyonlands National Park. It felt like our special hidden place. We had no idea that in coming years the area would be overrun by rock climbers who left their chalk marks and holes all over the rocks. We camped under the cottonwoods by the then mostly dry creek that gave the place its name. My brother would spend a good part of the week snoring away, the drugs that his doctor had prescribed back in Austin finally kicking in. This was the beginning of a cycle we would watch play out over the years as various doctors tried to perfect the chemical formula. Too heavy a dose and he became completely numb; too light and he became, in one doctor’s poetic word, florid. Another thing we didn’t know then was that we would get to see both of these extremes play out in the course of our trip. There is always a lag time with the medication and, unbeknownst to us, he stopped taking the drugs halfway through the week.
It felt like our special hidden place. We had no idea that in coming years the area would be overrun by rock climbers who left their chalk marks and holes all over the rocks.
Meanwhile Hones and I were doing some medicating of our own. If there is a better place on the planet to take mushrooms I don’t know it. Start with the fact that the orange rock that curls and crests in every direction above you makes you feel like you’re tripping already. I hadn’t yet put together that my brother’s own psychotropic experimentation during his twenties, much more extensive than my own, had been one of the causes of his current state.
On the ledge above our campsite was an ancient granary. Anasazi, we would have labelled it then; Ancestral Puebloan now. By southwestern standards it was decidedly modest; its single room sat tucked below an overhang of sandstone the size of a bus, the room itself built of rock, dried mud, and sticks. It was a masterpiece of organic architecture, made of the same material, color, and shape as the browlike overhang it appeared to support.
If “cultural appropriation” was a phrase people used back then, I didn’t know it. I was aware of the basic concept, however. I understood enough to know that a tripping white boy having a supposedly spiritual experience while contemplating a Native American granary was suspect. In fact, a few weeks before our road trip I’d gone to a reading by the writer Sherman Alexie, who seemed to delight in mocking his Boulder audience.
“Why don’t you explore your own roots?” he challenged us. “And leave our roots alone.”
Alexie’s own roots grew from the Spokane and Coeur d’Alene peoples of the inland Pacific Northwest, but he started his reading by telling a long farcical story about going in search of his long-lost fictitious grandfather in England.
Back then quite a few people would have referred to Alexie as an Indian, a name that some of my Navajo acquaintances prefer to this day, as did Alexie himself at the time, finding the newer names pretentious.
“I like Republicans better than liberals,” he said. “At least Republicans don’t want to be us.”
I got it. Alexie was by nature a provocateur, and he liked poking the Boulder folk, who tended to run toward the New Age. But there were things he didn’t know.
For one, he didn’t know that the ideas he was expressing about sticking to your own culture would calcify into a kind of dogma, one propagated through a medium, the internet, whose influence he could not have imagined, and that what once had sounded edgy would grow rote and rigid. Somehow along the way we would forget that throughout most of history there existed, in contrast to but coincident with the actual pillaging of people different than ourselves, the noble idea that we should learn from and embrace other cultures, and take what is best from them to apply to our own attempts to live well. This idea would fade over the next decades as the influence of the dogmatic left, rising in concert with and in reaction to the dogmatic right, grew in disproportionate power to their small numbers, magnified through the new mediums, and people became wary of even the best aspects of learning from different cultures. The upside of this would be respect, the downside a frightened caution about diving into the thick of lives other than our own, lives that can reveal possible ways of being on this planet.
I had no inkling of this back then, but Alexie’s talk got me thinking. I brooded for a bit and then did what I often did when I was pondering these issues: I went to see the smartest man I knew. Reg Saner was a poet and essayist who had spent many years hiking and climbing in the desert southwest, while contemplating the people who had lived on the same land for thousands of years. He also happened to share some of Alexie’s scorn for “spiritual types.”
“Certainly what he says is valid,” Reg told me. “We’ve taken everything but their history and culture and now we’re going after that.”
Reg had recently written an essay about the ancient Stone Lions shrine on the Pajarito Plateau of New Mexico, describing how the shrine had “grown so encumbered with deer-antler ‘offerings,’ baubles, and oddments that Indians finally cleared it away.”
But while his criticism might sound contemporary, he drew the line in a common-sense manner that is often missing today.
“What is lacking is respect. The Pueblo people have every right to keep us from going to their sacred places,” he said with a smile. “But if they tried to stop us from thinking about them that would be another matter.”
He explained that when thinking about the world, and trying to understand it, it would be ridiculous to restrict one’s thinking to one people and one culture. A strong mind roams.
In his book Reaching Keet Seel, he wrote: “To the extent that humankind is one family, they were my ancestors, too, though in a relation more metaphoric than actual.”
He would have been shocked at how controversial that statement would become in the timid time known as the future. And I’m sure he would have found the idea that we should all stick to our own cultural turf regressive and limiting.
As it turned out, Reg would continue to explore the land he loved, making art and thinking hard about the people who had lived there and lived there still. He would do so for another quarter of a century, until his death in 2021 at the age of ninety. Those were often hard years. I tried to visit him every summer and one of the things we talked about when we got together was literature, both reading it and the struggle to write it. But another bond was our familial experiences with mental illness, and Reg’s role as the caretaker of his struggling son.
As for Sherman Alexie, his future, unscripted back then, would not be the one I would have guessed at. He continues to write, speak, publish, and provoke to this day. But he would be accused of sexual misconduct by a number of women at the height of the Me Too movement, postpone the paperback edition of his memoir, and offer a public apology.
None of this was on my mind our last night at Indian Creek as I hiked past the granary toward the rocks above. The wind had stirred up the desert world. A green skunkbush shook like a go-go dancer. Shadows scraped low across the ground, with only the massive purple shade of the buttes keeping still. Despite its wind-ruffled feathers, a raven navigated onto the branch of a dead juniper.
“Metaphor is the fundamental path of the imagination,” wrote Doug Peacock, a hero of mine whom I was still a decade away from meeting, and I challenge anyone to walk through a landscape of the sort I was inside without breaking into paroxysms of simile and metaphor-making.
I hiked away from the granary, up toward the rock fins. I could see the vague flickering of the fire back at our campsite, where I had left my brother still snoring in his tent. The sun was dying as I climbed up the side of one of the largest buttes. “Metaphor is the fundamental path of the imagination,” wrote Doug Peacock, a hero of mine whom I was still a decade away from meeting, and I challenge anyone to walk through a landscape of the sort I was inside without breaking into paroxysms of simile and metaphor-making. The simile of the moment was that of a ship, and as I climbed farther up the butte I reached the great ship’s bow. One last mushroom-shaped rock jutted like a bowsprit, and I grabbed hold of a twisting branch of iron-blue juniper and pulled myself up onto it. The wind now challenged me to a nasty game of King of the Hill, and my windbreaker flapped like a luffing sail. But I had a full view of the rock needles and mushrooms below, and a gaudy sunset that had begun to soak Island in the Sky with salmon tones. Behind the gauzy image of pink rock, the sky was bruised a darker violet, marked by an even darker purple of tattered clouds sliced by slashes of orange.
As if that wasn’t enough—and it was, it’s what I had been waiting all week for without knowing it—something made me look over my other shoulder. And there, above a dip in the craggy outline of the dark orange plateau, emerged a sliver of white gold. It rose like a thing being born, tentative, but assertive. It was moonrise like I’d never seen before. I watched as the orb grew yellow, huge, full. The week so far had felt claustrophobic despite all the beauty. I was just learning a lesson that I would learn again and again over the next twenty-nine years: that mental illness is contagious. But as my head swiveled back and forth between setting sun and rising moon, everything seemed to be breaking out into the open. The moon was now a glowing yellow-white ball that had been forgotten by a giant child on top of the crags, its fullness marred only by the gray-blue cloud in its lower left corner.
This may not have been my place, but I felt the moonrise in my blood and bone.
The very first doctor would speak to me in a quiet voice and then walk me over to a screen that held an MRI. He would point to the butterfly patterns of my brother’s cerebral ventricles. They were beautiful if you could divorce yourself from what they signified. While the doctor studied me, I studied the patterns that looked like a Rorschach test but were in fact a picture of my brother’s brain.
“Notice how it’s enlarged in there,” the doctor said, pointing with a pencil to the white area at the center of the picture. I had no idea what a normal cerebral ventricle looked like, so it didn’t look particularly large to me, but I nodded anyway. The doctor was a short, pale man with a nose that sliced out of the middle of his face like a razor. His voice had roughly the same inflection as a robot’s. But to me he was less an individual than the first in a series of doctors over the years, a group, a type, who all stuck to the same message.
“You need to remember it’s a physical sickness,” he said. “It’s just like having a bad kidney or heart.”
I nodded again, though it didn’t seem exactly like that to me. It wasn’t my brother’s kidney, after all, but his brain. And the difference, I would often think later, is that if your kidney is bad it doesn’t start talking to you and telling you to do things.
I don’t remember the names of the drugs that first doctor prescribed—I would get better at telling Clozapine from Clozaril, and Haldol from Abilify, as time went on, but back then I was still a beginner. What I could see, even then, was that those first drugs were an unfortunate case of overkill. Maybe that was necessary, but it seemed too much. That initial numbing, I’m pretty sure, would mark the beginning of my brother’s suspicion of medication.
Though the present essay is about both my brother and the moon, I have tried to avoid the easy move of pairing lunacy and lunar. The word lunatic, as you may know, comes from the Latin word luna, meaning moon, and it was once believed by some that people’s mental states were influenced by the phases of the moon. There may be some truth to this, but as far as the moon leading to lunacy, I prefer to put it over in the big pile of hooey with the other mental illness myths I’ve collected over the years.
Perhaps the most prominent of these is the old image of the unjustly incarcerated patient. What the next decades would teach me was the opposite: just how hard it is to get someone the help they so obviously need. Not long after our trip, I would reread One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, hoping to get some insight into my brother’s sickness. I ended up throwing the book across the room. In college I had loved it but now it seemed like sheer crap. Over the years I would begin to be disgusted by other glossy romantic takes on “madness.” If I ever get around to writing an essay or editorial about the current treatment of the mentally ill, I know just what I’ll call it: “In Defense of Nurse Ratchet.” Maybe Cuckoo’s Nest was accurate when it was written. But times have changed. The freedom those inmates sought is now all too available. These days we just open the door wide and send the afflicted marching out.
It was with a start that I realized the blue-gray cloud in the corner of the moon wasn’t a cloud at all. I now remembered something that my brother, during one of his better moments, had read out loud to us from the newspaper while eating eggs and pancakes in a Moab diner the morning after our grueling bike ride.
“Listen to this,” he said. “The last lunar eclipse of the century will occur on Thursday night at seven. That would be cool to see.”
It was getting dark, but I ran back down the spine of the rock until I was above the granary and started yelling down to camp. I was too far away and worried that if I climbed down I’d miss the eclipse myself. But somehow Hones looked up from the fire to see me crossing my arms as if signaling to a rescue plane. When he saw me gesturing for them to come up, he thought “no way,” but he moved close enough to hear one word—“moon”—and to remember. Ten minutes later he and Nina had joined me up on the high rock to watch the double spectacle of sun and moon.
Wind rippled our coats and sand stung our eyes, but we jutted out our faces anyway. Purple ruffled vertebrae of clouds arced above a sky bleeding from orange to purple. But the moon was the main show. It looked like someone was erasing it bit by bit, and so, as it rose higher and higher, there was less and less of it. What remained shone like a radiant cup, then a skullcap, then a beanie, then a blazing boomerang of light. As the light was swallowed, what remained became most striking. At first a mere outline, it now turned a strong, deep orange.
“Pretty fucking cool,” Hones pronounced. I wrapped my arm around Nina. They told me they had heard my brother snoring in his tent but hadn’t tried to wake him, and while I felt some slight guilt, it was now too dark to go back and get him. I decided that was okay. I hated that the drugs might numb him to even this most dramatic and wild of moments.
The laundry list of things I didn’t know was a long one.
Perhaps above all else, I didn’t know and couldn’t have imagined that our government could be so fragile, so susceptible to corruption and demagoguery, that the institutions I and so many generations had grown up with would be shaken to their core to the point where, twenty-nine years later, I could not be certain our democracy would survive. Like most of us, I would have laughed if you’d told me that the boorish real estate developer who had just avoided bankruptcy and had his assets, including the Plaza Hotel, seized, would one day become president. In short, I didn’t know a time of profound darkness would descend on the country.
But I also didn’t know that the reaction to Trump’s rise would be its own sort of retraction from the light. That dogma and scolding would often replace thought and study. That, like the Sneetches of Dr. Seuss, new prejudices would replace the old, and that historical empathy, the work of understanding different times and cultures in their own context, not our own, would be tossed out. That the place where so much of life happens, the messy middle, a place guided by life not rules, would be abandoned by both extremes.
Though the country was certainly already split back then, it hadn’t yet calcified into a dogmatic right and a dogmatic left, leaving many of us feeling stranded. While the intolerance of one side would be more blatant and dangerous it would be mirrored in the other, each hewing to an orthodoxy that allowed for little variance. Free and independent thought and speech, not to mention nuance and humor, would go out the window.
As for my brother, he would remain stuporous for the rest of our time at Indian Creek, but his mind would wake, likely from not taking his pills, and he would grow florid as we drove home, an experience that Hones, trapped in the backseat with him, would never forget.
“I feel as if language has control of me,” my brother would say to me between hour-long monologues.
“What does that mean exactly?” I asked from the front seat.
“It means I have to be very careful about what I say.”
But he wasn’t careful, at least not to our ears, and his words flowed from Moab all the way back to Boulder.
Over the next years his diagnosis, like his state of mind, would always be in flux, running the gamut from extreme bipolar to schizoaffective to schizophrenic. We would learn to fear the last word most. That first doctor described schizophrenia vividly to my mother. “The death of a living child,” he called it.
But we wouldn’t, or couldn’t, believe that.
Soon the thin shine of a bald head was all that was left of the moon, a halo hovering above. When the last sliver of light disappeared like sun setting over the water, a shadow moon floated in the sky. A million stars shone around it, stars that would fade again in another hour when moonlight returned.
The moon’s light extinguished, we were left in the dark. Despite the stars, it was almost pitch black, and Nina realized at the same moment that we were trapped atop a steep rock.
“That eclipse is the last thing we will ever see,” she joked.
But Hones, former Boy Scout, pulled a headlamp out of his coat and handed it to me.
“Lead on, Captain,” he said.
We climbed down the steep rock sides, groping, feeling our way along, eerie rock Gorgons illuminated by starlight and the swiveling beam.
“I know you love your wife,” Hones said. “But how about a little light for me?”
Despite a few touchy moments when we lowered each other down, we got—as we’d gotten all night—absurdly lucky. We managed to climb right down the same route we had come up, the only route as far as we knew. Nina gave a little cheer of amazement when we reached flat ground. I twisted off the headlamp and we stared up at the orange moon-rock that hung in the sky.
“Your poor brother,” Nina said as we hiked back across the dry creekbed to camp. Of course she just meant that my brother was unlucky not to have seen the moon, but that would not be the last time those words would be coupled together in coming years.
I called to my brother, and he stumbled out of the tent. We told him about the eclipse.
He stared up at the moon.
I knew I would always remember that night, but there was so much else that I, caught in the amber of time, didn’t know.
Hones resurrected the fire and prepared our evening feast. He cooked two dozen hot dogs with Cholula hot sauce, then toasted tortillas filled with turkey, salsa, and jalapeño Monterey Jack. We opened a bottle of wine and watched the overexuberant sparks as they tried to escape from our fire and ignite the surrounding tamarisk.
After a while I wandered away from camp and settled on a rock near the creekbed to watch the rest of the moon’s show. Glimmers of white returned to the shadowy peach pit, spreading from the left side. Soon the white carved out wider patches for itself. It was a lunar striptease revealing shining, luminescent moon-flesh. In one night we had gotten to see a month’s worth of moons. At 10:37, over three and half hours after the eclipse began, I found myself looking up at a run-of-the-mill moon. But then, five minutes later, one final touch: In a spectacular afterthought, a double aureole appeared. Rainbow colors emanated from the orb and I couldn’t suppress an audible “Ahhhh.”
I looked down by the light of the moon and saw I had covered a quarter of my new journal with the night’s notes and sketches. My hand had been moving at a high speed as I chronicled what I saw. My wrist ached. My brother too was a furious scribbler, filling notebook after notebook. At that point I had not published a single book, but many would come over the next years. Like my brother I would hear voices and like him I would be compelled to write them down.
When I got back to the camp I saw that Nina had taken our sleeping bags out of the tent so that we could see the stars. My brother was already asleep, and Hones had thrown his bag up on a high ledge above camp so that he could see the sun rise. I hiked up to his ledge and gave him a hug good night. Then I climbed back down and crawled into the sleeping bags with my wife and we slept under the gaze of the moon.